Matt Flash wrote:If it was Aries vs. Gatson, just for the sake of a big name vs. small name, I don't think anyone would give Gatson a chance in hell.
1) That doesn't mean Gatson can't win. Well, in the specific case of Aries, it's possible that they have some sort of restrictions in terms of who they can job him to. But there's nothing to say that Brandon Gatson can't pin Kevin Steen or Chris Sabin.
2) "There's no way that one guy can beat that other guy" provides better heat for a match than "neither one of these guys is gonna win in the next round, so who cares who wins this one."
Granted, you could turn that on it's head and say since no one expects either guy to get to the second round, we as the crowd will be accordingly quiet and unresponsive, but both those guys can get a reaction. I think when the time comes, they'll put peoples' fears to rest. At least I hope so.
I'm sure the match will go over just fine. I'm sure they all will. It just strikes me as a mistake. BOLA is going to sell out regardless, and people tend to buy it as a two-pack... you don't actually need to overload Night One with big matches. Given that, the tournament should be structured in a way that gets everyone as over as possible. Spanky doesn't get any more over beating Aries than he does beating Nick Jackson (or a comparable babyface)... Spanky's already a star in the promotion and doesn't need a rub. But Brandon Gatson gets a *lot* more over beating Aries than he does beating Nick Jackson. Which does more for Gatson going forward, beating a big star who's the current ROH champ, or beating a guy who's won even fewer PWG singles matches than Gatson has? I mean, if you want to push Gatson, really push him.
I don't even really know why I'm complaining about it... the first round is always booked in this same imbalanced way, and the tourney always comes out fine. It just seems like they don't get nearly as much value out of the requisite fifteen jobs as they should. If you do it right, you can have five guys come out of this tourney with momentum, not just one or two.






